Writing / Essay

Why your second operations hire fails

The first hire fixes things by effort. The second needs a system to step into, and there usually isn’t one.

Your first operations hire succeeded by knowing everyone and working late. The second arrives to a job that only exists in the first one’s head. I see this most in firms of fifty to a hundred people, usually two or three years after the first hire, when the owner decides operations needs more than one person and is then surprised when the new person struggles.

What the first hire really built

Think about how the first hire did the job. They joined when the firm was small enough to know by name. They learned which customer always pays late, which supervisor needs a reminder on Thursdays, which supplier will hold a slot if you call before nine. They fixed problems by walking over to someone’s desk. Over time they became the place where every awkward question went, and the firm worked because they were there.

None of that is written down, and most of it was never a decision. It is a set of habits and relationships, and it works because one person carries all of it. When the firm adds a second person, the owner usually splits the work by area: you take the customer side, I keep the suppliers. The new person then finds that every task in their half depends on something the first person knows and has not had time to explain.

What the second hire walks into

In the first month the new hire asks a lot of questions, and the first hire answers them between other things. By the second month the questions slow down, because the new hire can see they are adding to an already full day. They start guessing. Some guesses are wrong, and the first hire quietly fixes them, which takes longer than doing the work themselves would have.

By the fourth or fifth month the owner hears that the new person “isn’t picking it up”. Sometimes that is true. More often the new person is capable and has been given a role with no edges: no clear list of what they decide, no record of how things are done, no measure of whether a week went well. A dental group I worked with went through two practice operations managers in eighteen months before anyone noticed that both had been hired into the same undefined job.

The first hire is often the last to see it. They are proud of what they built and tired from carrying it, and handing it over feels like explaining something obvious. That is not a character flaw. They have simply never needed to describe the job, because they have always been the one doing it.

Build the job before you fill it

Before you hire the second person, spend a few weeks making the job exist outside the first person’s head. Start with a list of the recurring work, everything that happens daily, weekly and monthly, and next to each item, who decides and who does it. The first hire will usually produce most of this in two or three sittings if you ask the questions and let them talk. Write it down as they speak, then tidy it.

Then choose a handful of the routines that matter most, the ones where a mistake costs money or a customer, and write each one down as a short page: what triggers it, what done looks like, where the information lives, and who to call when it goes wrong. You are not writing a manual. You are writing enough that a capable stranger could do the task on their second attempt.

Next, decide what the second hire owns outright. Pick an area they can run without checking in, with a clear boundary, and tell the rest of the firm. A support team lead I worked with gave her new hire sole ownership of the weekly escalation review, with the authority to reassign tickets. Within a month the new hire was the person people went to for that, and the lead had a day back each week.

Finally, give both of them a few simple numbers to look at together every week: orders waiting, jobs overdue, invoices not raised. Shared numbers give the new person a way to show progress that does not depend on the first person’s judgement, and they give the first person a reason to let go.

Done this way, the second hire spends their first months doing the work instead of decoding it, and the first hire finally has time for the larger problems they have been putting off for a year. The written routines also stay behind, which matters on the day either of them leaves.

This is example content from the Card theme. Replace it with your own, or move it to the bin.

Read enough? Tell me what you are working on.